WARNING: GRAPHIC CONTENT - Servicemen of the Ukrainian National Guard take positions in central Kyiv, February 25, 2022. REUTERS/Gleb Garanich
Patrick J. Buchanan: Did We Provoke Putin’s War in Ukraine?
Whatever we may think of Putin, he is no Stalin. He has not murdered millions or created a gulag archipelago. Nor is he “irrational,” as some pundits rail. He does not want a war with us, which would be worse than ruinous to us both. Putin is a Russian nationalist, patriot, traditionalist and a cold and ruthless realist looking out to preserve Russia as the great and respected power it once was and he believes it can be again.
When Russia’s Vladimir Putin demanded that the U.S. rule out Ukraine as a future member of the NATO alliance, the U.S. archly replied: NATO has an open-door policy. Any nation, including Ukraine, may apply for membership and be admitted.
We’re not changing that. In the Bucharest declaration of 2008, NATO had put Ukraine and Georgia, ever farther east in the Caucasus, on a path to membership in NATO and coverage under Article 5 of the treaty, which declares that an attack on any one member is an attack on all.
Read more ....
WNU Editor: The world does not revolve around the U.S.. There are many reasons why this invasion was launched at this point of time. The lack of leadership and diplomacy from the U.S. and a failure to truly understand the dynamics at play from the US President is certainly one of them, but not the main one.
I first blame President Putin for starting this war, and a failure of the Russian Foreign ministry to use diplomacy with Europe to resolve the Ukraine war in the Donbas. Regular readers of this blog know that I have been saying this for years. Resolve Donbas, and you will deflate all the tensions and national security concerns of the Kremlin. Putin had all the cards in his hand to build a European coalition to make this happen, but he failed, and catastrophically.
The second person I blame is Ukraine President Zelensky. He was overwhelmingly elected as President on the promise to end the conflict in eastern Ukraine. His solution which was accepted by all sides in the conflict, was to accept Minsk 2 and give the Russian regions of Ukraine a degree of autonomy concerning language and culture. Why he decided to drop this promise and commitment right after he was sworn into office will be something that historians will look at and say was the major mistake in his Presidency. They will also say that his sworn commitment in October of last year to use military force to retake the Donbas AND Crimea set into motion the war that we are seeing now, and what finally made the decision for Putin to launch an invasion was Zelensky's musings last weekend before the war to make Ukraine a nuclear military power.
The third group I blame are the leader's of Europe. They all saw and knew what would happen if the Ukraine war in the eastern regions were not resolved. Instead, they choose to stay on the sidelines and hope everything would work itself out. Sighhh .... hope is not a strategy, and now Europe's leaders and their governments are terrified on what is happening.
Totally Agree…
ReplyDelete"Why he decided to drop this promise and commitment right after he was sworn into office will be something that historians will look at and say was the major mistake in his Presidency."
ReplyDeleteI don't think we need historians to debate this one. As much as you refuse to accept it WNU, autonomy in those regions is a short-term solution that will result in the annexation of them. Autonomy is just one step-away from declaring independence, as they have just done, and we know where that goes, right? Crimea?
As I have seen on your reporting since 2014, you have been nothing short of a Russian apologist; for Crimea, for Donbas, and even now, in your thinly veiled attempt to place blame on Ukraine, as you are want to do, you continue to act as an apologist. "Putin is to blame... but hold on, this is on Zelensky's shoulders too!"
You sound like many of the Russian ambassadors who in each country are defending Putin, you just know yourself you can't point a single finger at Putin without pointing several others at Ukraine.
I do not know how your family in Ukraine tolerate your politics, I really don't.
So Iraq, Syria, Yemen and Libya are not considered civilized? Or is it only ok when usa and NATO bomb countries and massacre civilians
ReplyDelete"The third group I blame are the leader's of Europe. They all saw and knew what would happen if the Ukraine war in the eastern regions were not resolve"
ReplyDeleteWhen war broke out in Slovenia , the Europeans did nothing. They did not have to use maritime capacity to move equipment to a different continent. They did not need a fleet of heavy airlift aircraft to move troops. They simply could use the roads and rails of Europe. Slovenia happened in their back yard. They did nothing. Slovenia was over in two weeks.
The Croat-Serbian War over Vukovar and Osijek happened. The Euro-trash did nothing.
How much of a heads up do the European leaders need?
They got involved Bosnia. But only with US help.
The Europeans did little to nothing in Yugoslavia. What would anyone think they would do anything about Ukraine?
Anti-troll celebrated the Rape of Kuwait by Iraq.
ReplyDeleteHe wish he could have been there and he was in spirit.
lost Ukraine photo propaganda only cry
ReplyDeleteyou talk funny like
ReplyDeletetonto in lone ranger
The editor's opening sentence pretty much nails it. Unfortunately a number of our leaders appear to have trouble understanding this. When someone has an inflated view of themselves and acts in accordance with that erroneous view of themselves, bad decisions are often the result.
ReplyDeleteWhile "we" as in our government did/do have role in this, Mr. Buchanan gives "us" to much credit. This isn't surprising as he appears to have a mental block whereby he has to blame us for everything.
While we cannot know for certain, I will forever believe that had Trump remained POTUS this war would not have happened. Whether the election was stolen or not when we lost Trump as POTUS we lost a great leader who was respected and even feared by all sides.
As I understand it, he is speaking at CPAC tonight. While I'm sure the media will make sure his speech is censored, I'm sure people in attendance will provide commentary. I hope he is able to get past the justifiable bitterness about a likely stolen election and focus on forward looking solutions.