REMOVING TROOPS - President Barack Obama addresses the nation about the way forward in Afghanistan and his plan to remove 10,000 American troops from the country by the end of this year, with a total of 33,000 troops by next summer, at the White House, June 22, 2011. White House photo by Chuck KennedyMilitary Leaders Know Obama’s Decision Is A Disaster -- Robert Kagan, Washington Post
The press is reporting that the top military leaders have “endorsed” President Obama’s Afghan troop withdrawal decision. With all due respect to the fine reporters, that is not the news. Under our Constitution, military leaders have no choice but to endorse the president’s decision after giving him their best advice. They could resign, of course, but to have the entire senior military leadership resign over a president’s decision contrary to their advice would be a disaster, and not least for the troops on the ground.
Make no mistake, however. The entire military leadership believes the president’s decision is a mistake, and especially the decision to withdraw the remainder of the surge forces by September 2012. They will soldier on and do their best, but as the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Adm. Mike Mullen, put it, in characteristic understatement, they believe the decision will increase the risk to the troops and increase the chance that the mission will not succeed.
Read more ....
My Comment: I hope that the American generals are wrong, and President Obama is right. But for one retired general in Britain .... he has doubts.
What is my prediction .... Afghanistan will muddle on, and when U.S./NATO forces finally leave .... they will revert back to their old habits of warlords, religious extremism, and tribal conflicts. Will this be a disaster for us .... no .... but for the Afghans .... yes.
1 comment:
ten years for what? We have just found out (see NY Times) that a Bin Laden cell phone connects Al Qaeda to Pakistan Intelligence! Why not take on that bunch of terrorists too? And while we are fighting there let us also argue that the budget is out of whack.
As Lincoln made clear, our political leadership determines our military goals and not the reverse, for better or worse...and that is what makes us different from a banana republic or so many nations in the Middle East.
Post a Comment