Wednesday, August 23, 2023

U.S. And Western Officials Say Ukraine Has Mishandled The Counteroffensive

New York Times: Ukraine’s Forces and Firepower Are Misallocated, U.S. Officials Say 

Ukraine’s grinding counteroffensive is struggling to break through entrenched Russian defenses in large part because it has too many troops, including some of its best combat units, in the wrong places, American and other Western officials say. 

The main goal of the counteroffensive is to cut off Russian supply lines in southern Ukraine by severing the so-called land bridge between Russia and the occupied Crimean Peninsula. But instead of focusing on that, Ukrainian commanders have divided troops and firepower roughly equally between the east and the south, the U.S. officials said. 

As a result, more Ukrainian forces are near Bakhmut and other cities in the east than are near Melitopol and Zaporizhzhia in the south, both far more strategically significant fronts, officials say.  

Read more ....  

Update: West ‘perplexed’ by Ukraine’s strategy – NYT (RT)  

WNU Editor: I am not buying the above New York Times report blaming Ukraine for the failure of the counteroffensive. 

The US and its Western allies are the ones who are propping up the Ukraine Army. They pay the salaries. Provide the equipment and munitions. And more importantly .... providing most if not all of the intelligence that Ukraine uses to plan and launch their attacks.

It looks like some officials in Washington are now trying to wash their hands on this failed counteroffensive, and they are using the New York Times to blame it all on Kyiv. 

As I wrote in the previous post. The media narrative is changing. Even pro-Ukraine publications like 1945 are now starting to concede the obvious .... The Hard Truth: Ukraine Has No Realistic Path to Victory Over Russia (1945).

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

Fraud starting with zelenko theater actor, take a good look at Putin has nuclear warheads the guys already know they lost it then ask Europe and the USA for alms, in this we see teenagers dying in war and not the older people, we saw many girls disappearing on such a high scale that there was a complaint from the child traffickers themselves of something bigger happening, summary of the opera this lost lying war is just a smokescreen of a scandal involving people of political power covering up these disappearances of girls and corruption of money, food and weaponry ?? Ukraine always with its flag and false nationalism through there began the cradle of the abyss where everything bad like BioLabs started to be funded by the government itself ?? Absurd wolrd

fazman said...

You left out flat earth and covid ...oh oh and moon landing

Anonymous said...

The money going to help ukraine has been floated by said oligarchs in the shape of 100k vehicles speed boats models and vacation villas since the beginning of the war Now they see it????But yeah carry on the BS everyone is stupid

Mr Nobody said...

Concur with editor on this one.

NATO failed

a. To provide sufficient artillery

b. to provide sufficient air cover

c. allowing this attack without the above

Most important. In Colombia, Iraq, syria, Afghanistan, The Fig leaf was "our coalition Partners". Or the XXX "National Government" says.....

This is Bullshit. Those wars were directed in large part out of the MILGRP and the Combat Command HQ. whether SOUTHCOM or EUCOM etc... Just like this one.

The US can say (and they do). do x or y and we will cut off aid. OR transpose it ....IF you do not do x or y we cut off aid.

This also entails taking away the leaders ( in this case Zelinski and the rest of thug life) American visas, cutting off the bribe money (supplemental salary) and confiscating their overseas properties.

No, this catastrophe is the US Military's fault and dolts in the State Department.

You can blame the ukies for going along with it.

Anonymous said...

My sources tell me these observations are premature

Mr Nobody said...

If the observations are premature. ...then your choices are limited......

1. the Americans are doubly incompetent.

a. they let a bunch of amateurs run the show

b. They failed to use the tools of influence they have at hand to control their proxies/allies.


2. The Americans are criminally lazy

OR

3. God forbid.... and I do not think so.... but this world is full of monsters and possibilities.

a. .the conspiracy guys are right and this war is an effort to depopulate that part of the world and/or use the Ukrainians as human slavery ( child and female slavery) cattle to make money.



Either way. This is an American failure of political will or just plain stupidity.

take your pick.

Mr Somebody said...

In Belarus, Georgia, and Moldova, the Kremlin is waging a quiet war to consolidate its hegemony.

Russian Influence in Belarus, Georgia, and Moldova Is Growing

Anonymous said...

That's nice. This thread is about the Ukraine and who is responsible for the failed offensive

Anonymous said...

Cause and Manner of Death Released for Barack Obama’s Longtime Chef Tafari Campbell

Ever heard the term imperial presidency? We are beyond that now. Since many elections are stolen, election do not matter. They do not have to steal them all just enough to get above 50% and pass legislation. Like under Octavian we have the form of a Republic, but in actuality we are an empire.

Russia and the PRC are no different.

This is in part how you have to understand the war.

Anonymous said...

ok bud

so who is responsible for the failed offensive?

Anonymous said...

Offensive has not failed any more than the Russian offensive to take Bakhmut. In fact the current offensive is 5 times better than the Russian one with that ratio going toward +infinity.

The NYT and Blinken getting cold feet. And? Blinken is every much of a coward as Joe Biden. Blinken only has a stomach for political fights and then only after he has graduated college and determined the eventual winner. even at that Blinken is not a political trigger puller but support staff.

Blinken's knowledge of war is no deeper than a game of risk he may have played as a teen. less in fact. Like a college student dropping their course notes in the garbage after a final exam, Blinken probably lost any knowledge of the game of risk, when he finished the game and walked out of the room. Blinken is no more fierce than a naked mole rate and naked mole rats are fierce inside their warren!

The NYT are bunch of people in literal echo chamber. As predicted by scientists their brain waves are literally all in sync. They have or had decent Make 1 mod 1 brains which they have assiduously loaded with malware.

So the NYT and Blinker have cold feet and?

Anonymous said...

The USA doesn’t know how to fight wars anymore when isis and the talaban can chase you out with rifles and ied’s (yes I know that not true they just waited for public opinion to erode) . But the fact that the USA has not won a real war since ww2. I believe our current methods are only good against weaker opponents where we have superiority in everything.
I believe Ukraine has much more war fighting experience than any of our current officers. War often comes down to attrition and Russia has more bodies and equipment to lose.

Anonymous said...

The US won the Gulf War. Iraq was the world's 4th largest army at the time.

Did I miss a memo? Did the Us lose in Korea? the North Koreans, Chinese and Russians surely did not win.

The US defeated the Taliban in a few months. The Pakistanis then reconstituted the Taliban. Super whip smart people like Blinken did not want to fight the Pakistanis.

Anonymous said...

Ukraine should have transitioned to an insurgent guerrilla warfare model. Trying to fight a conventional war with a weaker army had predictable outcomes.

Anonymous said...

951.

That comment is extremely illogical and borders on the demented.

So are the ukies in mariupol yet? No! They have not even reach tokmak after almost 3 months of fighting.
They have not broken even 1 defensive line out of three.
No this offensive is not a fail,

by any standard it is an EPIC failure.

Anonymous said...

They do not have to reach Tokm0ok. They just have to interdict it. there is new invention called artillery. That rail line through Tokmok will be toast. All the Russian artillery and HQ between Robotyne and Tokmok (Fort Apache) are being brewed up.

Robotyne is on or behind the 1st defense line. So you lied.

Soon Pootin will have another crypto call up. your number will come up!

Anonymous said...

No genious it is not behind the defence line. And tokmak was an intermediate objective on the way south.

More fail

Anonymous said...

1238


EEEEEE Gads!!!!!

Just re-checked

You were right!!!

Robotyne is part of the 1st defensive line.

Well, unlike some of the neocon idiots and progressive liberals on this blog.. I will apologize. Good call on your part!!

My apologies for my mistake.

Have a GOOD DAY.

Anonymous said...

Well if the Intelligence Community is the source for the analysis, Ukraine will win very quickly...